14 replies [Last post]
moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11

Hi,

Here is some feedback :

Yesterday I tried for the second time to try out GameCommanderPro - first time around (when it was first mentioned on d-b forums) it messed up all my WTF folders/accounts so this time I decided I would try against a copy of my setup on another drive

http://www.gamecommanderpro.com/gettingstarted

is lacking the basic info:

Does GCP support virtualization of WTF or not ? ie do I need 1 Wow install or 5 to 5 box ? I thought it would support different WTF/virtualization but looks like I'm wrong - please correct me and do write in http://www.gamecommanderpro.com/gettingstarted that you need N wow folders if that's the case

Second there is very very unintuitive startup/setup very confusing (and also ugly huge fonts (I'm on w7 if that matters) and layout - not sure what graphic toolkit (reminded me of delphi) you are using but maybe considering using something else more native - but I digress) - the first thing I would like when I set 5 windows is that they don't show up all stacked on top of each other - also why do I have to click "active" before doing anything else ? why is it that after I save a layout then I start I get a choice between <Default> and the one I saved ? can I save "default" ?

When you click to not start now; you get lots of errors during startup (don't offer options which don't work)

How do I remove all borders to windows and yet still move them (I want to use 100% of my screen real estate) ?

I haven't been able to get past that / startup yet so I can't yet comment on the rest of the feature

I think you guys are on to something potentially great but it's far from ready yet, though I'd like to give it a chance - but I'm hoping that there is some easy way to setup windows location (even if that means entering coordinates; I'm not afraid of that as I use HotKeyNet at the moment)

Thanks (don't take personally my somewhat negative initial impression/feedback; it's for future improvement)

ps: reason I think virtualization isn't working is I tried the "high" button in settings for my main/tank account and "low" on the other 4 ; for 1 wow folder and they all changed to low rez (and still stack up uselessly by default - also sound is turned on on all 5... the medium/low setting should turn off sound imo)

Phil
Phil's picture
User is online Online
Joined: 06/30/2009
Posts: 443
Some answers to your questions

As we've said before, we do recognize the benefit of feedback, be it good or bad, in fact we probably gain more from the bad!

I accept that we probably did some strange things with the WTF files, but am concerned that you say that GCP messed up your accounts. I'm not aware of any way that this can happen (as we don't write to account data), so it would be really useful if you could please let me know how this manifested itself.

As to the WTF virtualization, the answer is yes it does. We do however recognize that the means by which you have to edit a configuration is a little cumbersome, and we are working on a layout painter / configuration editor which will achieve more of what I think you're looking for.

The current method is that, from the profile screen (select a profile and click edit) there is a settings button for each character. This presents a list of settings initially read from the WTF in the current folder for the character. You can edit an item by selecting it, changing a value and clicking update.

We are currently (i.e. been working on it today) changing our development system to address a number of issues with respect to support of future operating systems. By the end of the week GCP will be a 64 bit .net 3.5 application. As part of this upgrade, we will be addressing some of the "look and feel" issues, and, at some later date, plan to add a skinning feature.

We have been responding to customer feedback in continuing to improve our product. The general overview is that once you get it up and running, the program is very capable and easy, but the set-up was (and apparently is) letting us down. We have updated (and continue to update) the setup procedure, and as a result, I admit that the documentation has got a little behind. We have a project in place to address this, and I will make sure that your comments are included in the "things we need to fix" list.

Windows can be moved and sized by using layouts/show frames. The corresponding layouts/hide frames will maximize the real estate.

The default layout can be saved by not entering a name at the save prompt.

If you want to edit the files, they are stored in c:\gamecommanderpro and are as follows:

FormInfo<LayoutName>.txt contains the layouts for the GCP windows

Each line contains:
Left,Top,FormName,Visible,Width,Height
If Formname begins with "*" then width and height are obeyed, else they are not

WOWFormInfo<LayoutName>.txt contains the layouts for the WoW windows.
The order of data is:
Bottom
Left
Right
Top

The "do not start" currently enters a mode which is designed for developers so that we can run GCP without an attached game, and this behavior will be changed in the next release.

I'm sorry that you are frustrated with our startup procedure. We have improved it but are aware that it needs work yet. The problem we have is that we need to gather quite a lot of information to cope with the differing configurations that we come across, and doing this in an intuitive way still remains a challenge. In this regard, we are always glad to hear suggestions.

For this type of product, operating in so many different environments and providing such a wide range of capabilities, I'm not sure it will ever be "finished". I recognize your "not ready" comment is borne of your frustration, and I'm sorry that our start-up procedure has disappointed you, but if we can help you get past that, then I think you'll be pleased with the features of the main program.

I suggest that we have a support chat session to get you up and running, and rest assured that we will attempt to address all the issues that you have raised.

I thank you for taking the time to look at our product, and for taking the time to provide this feedback. We'd much rather hear about problems, than people just go away silently.

Thanks
Phil

__________________

Designer Of GameCommanderPro - www.GameCommanderPro.com
Designer Of KeyBlaster - www.keyblaster.com

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
Thanks for the quick reply -

Thanks for the quick reply - glad to know the WTF is indeed virtualized - I will try again

Some comment: even "without" frames (it's really without titlebar) there is still a fairly big frame visible around the wow windows - can you make an option to have totally frameless windows like HKN, Keyclone and others ?

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
another minor thing: resizing

another minor thing: resizing the settings window doesn't expand the list content

and another: if I make changes setting changes in the game (like turning off sound), they shouldn't be lost after I exit (you should save the virtualized config.wtf for each window not just overwrite it at the begining)

and another: if I gave the name of the account it should be selected (I use battle net) or at least again preserved when I exit

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
to turn sound off

doing a diff from with/without sound wtf you need to add (not edit... add as it's removed when sound is on)

SET Sound_EnableAllSound "0"

Can you add a sorting of the wtf and the option to add entries ? not just update existing ones - also please make it confirm/ask if you want to save when you updated and you close the window (the save button at top in middle of low/mid/high is easy to miss and making edits and loosing them is not good for users)

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
auto login
  1. don't echo password
  2. support "same as previous" (I have same password on all 5)
  3. support battle.net
  4. support authenticator
somehow I put what I think is my correct password yet it ended up with the password in the login field instead of the password (probably because it didn't understand the battle.net prompt...)
moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
random weirdness and more feedback

why when I click "active" (that again should be default?) does it change my main to green my second toon to yellow but keeps the other 3 red ?

I had to read the getting started twice carefully to finally find that to start broadcasting keys I have to use Ctrl-Enter ... should be in some basic menu with a shortcut/key binding next to it (self documenting)

Earlier I tried to use "Action" "Other command" but there is no help or contex or drop down to pick commands from...

What is the key binding for toggling active (and how do I change them ?)

If you make the mistake to redo a wizard you get a zillion "confirm overwrite" dialogs and there is no way but keep answering for all commands (no esc/abort or no "same answer for all same question")

Jeremy
Jeremy's picture
User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 2 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/14/2009
Posts: 268
Reply

moorea wrote:
Some comment: even "without" frames (it's really without titlebar) there is still a fairly big frame visible around the wow windows - can you make an option to have totally frameless windows like HKN, Keyclone and others ?

You can change your windows boarder width in you open desktop settings and go into advanced theme settings the is a border padding value.

When we release the layout editor this will most likely trim the borders off completely.

moorea wrote:
another minor thing: resizing the settings window doesn't expand the list content

and another: if I make changes setting changes in the game (like turning off sound), they shouldn't be lost after I exit (you should save the virtualized config.wtf for each window not just overwrite it at the begining)

and another: if I gave the name of the account it should be selected (I use battle net) or at least again preserved when I exit

moorea wrote:
doing a diff from with/without sound wtf you need to add (not edit... add as it's removed when sound is on)

SET Sound_EnableAllSound "0"

Can you add a sorting of the wtf and the option to add entries ? not just update existing ones - also please make it confirm/ask if you want to save when you updated and you close the window (the save button at top in middle of low/mid/high is easy to miss and making edits and loosing them is not good for users)

We do realize we need to make the settings editor a much nice form. For now if you want add stuff you can go into the C:\GameCommanderPro\Profile.GCP_Config\CHaracter.WTF

__________________

GameCommanderPro Graphics Designer / Software Engineer

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
live support: account disabled...

must be my lucky day :-)

your live support shows "this account has been disabled, please contact "

(I mean your showmypc account is disabled; not my gcp/forum/... account)

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
mouse broadcasting ?

after I got the signin errors; I needed to click ok in each 5 windows (no key binding for that - blizz's bug I guess) - how do I toggle mouse broadcasting ?

Jeremy
Jeremy's picture
User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 2 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/14/2009
Posts: 268
Alt-Enter

Alt-Enter

__________________

GameCommanderPro Graphics Designer / Software Engineer

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
Thanks for Alt-Enter - that

Thanks for Alt-Enter - that feature (the cursor showing) seems nice

Last question for tonight:

how do I move the big green/blue bar that appeared in the middle of my screen after I invited the party ?
they also are not layed out correctly on 1280x720 rez
yellow text is on top of each other / unreadable

Thanks

ps: how do you broadcast esc when esc is the key to remove broadcasting ? (I'm used to scrolllock or pause toggles)

Jeremy
Jeremy's picture
User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 2 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/14/2009
Posts: 268
/gcp lock will toggle locking

/gcp lock will toggle locking the gcp frames

To make ScrollLock toggle BC mode click Views/Advanced. Then in the upper left dropdown select Wizard*. Double click Setbroadcast and paste the following into that command

ExitKey Scrolllock
BroadCast 1

Save that then mouse over a wow window press Scrolllock you should see it appear in the Last Special Key Pressed. Click this and that will assign that as the hotkey for BC mode.

Note

It might be called something other than scrolllock if so replace that in the command.

__________________

GameCommanderPro Graphics Designer / Software Engineer

moorea
moorea's picture
User offline. Last seen 1 year 1 week ago. Offline
Joined: 07/13/2009
Posts: 11
/gcp lock worked to move the

/gcp lock worked to move the windows around - thx

but I then tried to make the program do something; the import spell isn't working for me - is that expected ?
(nothing at all happens when I click import; no error but no changes either)

I tried manually setting up a spell to key "h" name "hearthstone" and casting "Hearthstone" saved, uploaded, /rl'ed and pressing h does absolutely nothing either...

I spent several hours already and have yet to get further than invite + follow - I'm getting near the end of my rope...

Jeremy
Jeremy's picture
User offline. Last seen 4 weeks 2 days ago. Offline
Joined: 06/14/2009
Posts: 268
To import spells first type

To import spells first type /gcp export then do a /rl. You will then be able to use the import button in the spell DB

When you setup hearth what kind of action did you create?
For heath choos Other then type /use Hearthstone in the Enter Command To Execute field.

Hope this helps

__________________

GameCommanderPro Graphics Designer / Software Engineer